Depends on what type of fishing you do. It's great for trolling and bottom fishing, but if you like to chase fish and cast to fish, it definitely gets in the way. When I started playing with a fly rod, I decided my next boat would have minimal obstructions. I bought an Scout 18 with no top, no bimini and am very happy with it that way, but if I was sitting anchored or trolling, I would want a T-Top.
Striper77
Striper77