[MeanBean]

Want to buy a calcutta 250, but am also looking at a 955 although i think it is to big, have a 400 and love it.Any pros or cons? Thanks

 

[Leprechaun]

"Too Big" . . . To big for what?

Give us some idea what you want to use it for as I have some suggestions for about half of what those reels cost.

rgds, Leprechaun

 

[Hunt n' Fish]

I think either reel is a safe bet, and close in price, if you shop around. It just depends on what you like the feel of better.

I have a 965 and 955 and like the "feel" of the reel in my hand. However, I would rather a left hand conventional, so I am getting a 251 Calcutta, because I would rather keep the rod in my right hand while casting and retrieving. I prefer American, but if they can't get with it and make a left-hand model, I'll use foreign.

I've used the Calcuttas before and was impressed. They are nice reels. They have a more open spool that is easier to access to pick out knots and seem to be a little lighter. The Penn's have improved the 955 and 965 by grinding out the point that used to cover the spool.

So like I said, handle both, put them on a similar rod to what you'll be using, and get the one you feel most comfortable with.

Chris

 

[mattyblazer]

Bolth are of high quality

They are pretty comparable and it all comes down to what feels good in your hands, as mentioned by Chris. Personally I like the finish on the penns better, the shimanos are too pale looking.
Good luck

 

[MeanBean]

Looks like i will be getting a calcutta 250, want to spool it with 12 lb test and use it for weaks and fluke,the 955 just seems to big and heavy. reel will be on a st. croix 6' tidemaster casting rod.