NorEast Fishing Forum banner
1 - 20 of 25 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
416 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Rumor has it that porgy season was moved up to an opening day of June 25. Has anyone else heard this? I have seen nothing to confirm this, and I don't want to see anyone in trouble with DEC,due to mis-information. Have new regs. been set, that we are un-aware of? Thanks for any info.

SEAWOLF
 

· Banned
Joined
·
3,311 Posts
I heard that it could be moved too. It may be as soon as the 20th!!

On the sad side, I also heard that they might close the season to PRIVATE BOATS for a good part of the humpback run in September but keep it OPEN FOR PARTY BOATS?????

Who knows what is going on.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
How is Porgy Fishing This early

Do we see humpbacks this early? Last year I made it a point to keep only very large fish with a 20 minimum for myself since that's about all my family and I will eat.

This was last september, the first time I ever fished for porgies and I thought they were pretty big. Are the humpbacks just a fall phenomenon?

By the way, Dr. Fish, enjoy your reports, very insighful, keep them coming.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
416 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Thanks for the responses,guys!! As you can see,people have been hearing things,but nothing that can be confirmed. I know Capt. Ed from the Seawolf is salivating at the thought of targeting them on Tuesday. I warned him that he better be absolutely sure of the date,or he could get alot of people in trouble. If anyone hears anything concrete,please let us know. And thanks again to all !!!

SEAWOLF
 

· Registered
Joined
·
416 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Hi Finnegan!!
Porgy fishing last year was phenominal. Large porgies everywhere!! But to answer your question,there is no doubt that the larger ones show up in the late summer/early fall,as they school-up to migrate offshore.Fish up to 3 lbs. were very common all around the Island as well as N.Y. bight. Best time is end of August to middle of October. GOOD LUCK, and CATCH EM UP!!!!

SEAWOLF
 

· Banned
Joined
·
3,311 Posts
Thanks for the compliment Finnegan

Thank you. I'll keep the posts coming.

As for humpbacks, they are in our waters throughout the season but there are two shots each year at finding them in greater concentration.

The first is right now. Scup usually spawn at the same time as Weakfish in our waters, right around the new moon in June. If you check the reports and ask around, you'll hear about surfcasters who have recently landed and released jumbo porgies on whole skimmer clams that were meant for stripers.

The second real decent shot is as Seawolf described, in the fall when they school up for the annual migration to the offshore winter grounds. This can happen anywhere from late August to December, depending upon the water temps.

One interesting note, according to divers and commercial trawlers who I've spoken to about their porgie observations, it seems that scup are just like bluefish, who INSIST on schooling up only with fish of the same size range. It's as if the elders stick together and push the juvenile fish out of their schools and into their own.

Keep this in mind next time you start catching smaller fish. It could mean that it's time to move to another location in search of the pods of larger fish.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
1,874 Posts
New Regs Not Yet Official

The regulations should be official today and they are:

Porgy Opening Tuesday June 25 with a 10-inch minimum size limit and it will run through Nov. 30. There will be a two-week closure sometime in September but we don't have the exact weeks yet.

And Sea-Bass will be 11 ½ inch minimum size and a year round season.

Again I must stress that these are not official yet, but they could be as soon as this afternoon. Look for our announcement in out new Fisheries News Section on the Homepage.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
Thanks George

Think I'll go ahead and see about getting Tuesday Off!!! I went Porgy fishing three times last year and had a blast. However, kinda miffed about the number allowed, I mean does anybody really need 50? They are delicious though!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,776 Posts
While on the beach at Rocky Point throwing a clouser fly last night I caught six porgys. First time I ever caught scup on a fly ! I saw some commercial guys come in with buckets of big porgys, so I am guessing there are lots around and it should be a good year.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
PORGIES-BIG AND EARLY

EVERY YEAR WE WOULD FISH ATOP THE SOUTH CHANNEL BRIDGE(THAT IS UNTIL 9/11) LATE MAY,EARLY JUNE AND CATCH PORGIES UP TO 14"!!!
THIS WAS OF COURSE AFTER THEY SPAWNED AND WERE HEADED SEAWARD.
THEY LEFT THE NEWLY BORN (PINHEADS BEHIND TO FEND FOR THEMSELVES.MANY FISHERMAN FRIENDS REFUSED TO BELIEVE IT UNTIL WE STARTED TAKING PHOTOS.NO,WE DID NOT KEEP THEM.I CAN WAIT LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE FOR THE BEAUTIFUL FALL MONTH OF OCTOBER TO CATCH THE BIG
ONES.SINGLE HOOK,LIGHT LINES BEAUTIFUL WEATHER,PLENTY OF BAIT =PURE JOY!!!!!!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
416 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Hello Dr.Fish!!!
I have also made the same observations concerning the size of porgies. Not just for migratory purposes,but in general. If you find porgies and say the first 10 to 15 are short,then I would say 95% of them will be shorts. If you find keepers,the large majority of them will also be keepers. So whats the point? A well versed fisherman will know if shorts are coming up, it's better to move,and find different porgies,than to use up all your bait trying to find a keeper out of the bunch!! A very good observation,and a very good tip to our porgy anglers.

SEAWOLF
 

· Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
Which Boat to Go On

I haven't fished the NorthStar for porgies yet but I've had pretty good sucess on the DayBreak.

Spoke to the Northstar and they suggest showing up at the gate at 6:00 AM, because their expecting a lot of poeple, the Daybreak probaly won't get as crowded.

I need some help on which boat to go on Tuesday!!!
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top