You stopped my heart!
When you mentioned West Sayville, I thought of Shore Rd., which runs just north of Shellfish. Where myo old boat is. I had to find Nicholls Point Marina in the Yellow Pages to see it was in Oakdale. I was almost out the door... It really does suck, even w/o my boat being involved.
Bayport, huh? I think I see the light on in your house from here.