I caught an interesting shellfish also a few weeks back at Moses #2. It was a couple of inches long and looked like a shrimp or a crayfish without any claws and its tail was shaped like a spade. It was a light pink color. I called a biologist at the DEC the next day and describe the critter. I was told it was most likly a MANTIS SHRIMP. They are common on the South Shore surf and the stipers eat them like candy. You may have caught one of these shrimp.