NorEast Fishing Forum banner
1 - 17 of 17 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
2,086 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Many on this board have far, far more experience than me on this subject, but I thought I'd share this trick with anyone that, like me, is just starting out.

I discovered a way of targetting the biggest mahi in a school this summer on my friend's boat the Whitecap III. It might be well-known technique, but I've never read it, so here goes:

When you pull up to a pot or piece of floating debris with a school of mahi under it, throw out a handful or two of butterfish chunks to get them in the mood. Then rig the biggest whole butterfish you can find just like you'd rig it for tuna (hide the hook through the mouth in the belly). When you lob out the big butterfish, a regular size mahi will grab it and run - let her go with it: keep your bail open or your reel in freespool and let her run. The bigger fish will see your fish running and shadow it. When your fish drops the bait to turn it around to swallow, a big one will come right up and steal it out from under your fish's nose. That's when you set the hook. I figured this out accidentaly when using a live snapper for bait. I tried to set the hook on a smaller fish, but it couldn't really get the bait in its mouth, so I yanked the bait out of its mouth by mistake and a much bigger fish came out of nowhere and nailed it. On that trip we managed to pull from a school of mostly 8#-10# fish two 18# females and a 22# bull (which I had a blast with on 15# spinning gear). Hope this help someone catch a big one!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
13,099 Posts
jtzannes, thanks for the tip, although I have thrown handfuls of bait to them, I never tried it exactly the way you explained. Here's another tip for those who may not know, when you hook one up, don't reel it in right away, keep it in the the water until a 2nd. one is hooked up, seems to get them to bite better.

MakoMatt
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
67,033 Posts
Matt,
If you keep one hooked up and in the water the school will follow the boat even if its drifted well away from the structure, if you pull that fish out of the water the rest of the school will turn around and head right back tot he structure.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,086 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Makos Mike and Matt

Very true about keeping the school by the boat. A word of warning to anyone thinking about trying this: you lose the mahi you're keeping in the water and you lose the whole school - when it swims away in its "caution" colors it will not hit another bait and neither will any of the other fish in the school - they'll turn off like a light. I caught a lot of flak from my friends once because of this.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
27,335 Posts
Matt - keepin' the first one in the water & on the hook works great - sometimes almost too good.

Was fishing the La Guiada <spelling> Banks (Venezuela)last February. Got into a large school of Mahi that were under a floating tree stump or log about size of a telephone pole. School had to number at least 50 fish -we were the first on the scene.
We're doing the keep 'em in the water until the second is hooked thing. I had one on the line - good size. All of a sudden there's a jerk & the line goes slack. I'm thinkin' **** -sucker got off. I start to reel in what I figure is an empty line. Wait - there's still something on here - little heavy - but it's not fighting - strange?

Finally get what was left of the Mahi out of the water just in time for one of the other guys to hook up on one of the wahoo drawn into the school of Mahi.

Tell ya - what I had was a decent size fish judging by the size of the head. Most that were boated (around a dozen in 10 minutes were around 3 1/2 to four feet. That wahoo bit mine off nice & clean right behind the gill plate. Looked like someone took an axe to the fish.

(This post edited by wader on 02/27/2003)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
13,099 Posts
wader, you got it right, that's the way to do it, sounds like that was a great trip, fishing for big ones like that is the best!!! Also, take your photos ASAP, they lose those brillant colors real quick!!!

MakoMatt

(This post edited by MakoMatt on 02/27/2003)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
192 Posts
Wahoo........

I was fishing the Sunbeam A party boat out of Niantic Ct. Last Oct.we were into some small mahi. I hooked up with a 2lber had him up to boat. I had a 50lb leader on, so I lifted him up to release him, as the fish got to rail
I was about to grab him when something
smacked my arm.I looked down just in time to see a good size Wahoo with my mahi in its mouth hit the water and run.I was totaly taken by surprise
and the rest of the crew had a good laugh, It stayed with the mahi for couple of min. then left. Ouch!!!!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
13,099 Posts
Matrix1, very nice fish, that it was I meant about taking the photos right away, they loose their color. Sometimes smacking them right between the eyes with a bat can bring back the color a bit for the photos.

Makomatt
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,369 Posts
Mahi fishing

The only thing different I've learned to do is rotate the fish left in the water.I have come up on Huge schools of Mahi on the Islamorada hump.After a few minutes we leave a second fish in the water and pull out the first one. I find that sometimes if you leave the fish in the water to long it becomes
less active or gets off the hook. So we rotate.
T.T.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
27,335 Posts
Matt - that picture above of the Mahi is of the ones Bennie & I were taking in Venezuela. Matrix just rotated the picture so it was easier to veiw.

Over the coarse of the 3 days we were fishing the Bank - we landed somewhaere in the neighborhood of 20 to 30 of those - all abbout the same size.

Now picture the size of the Wahoo that was able to bit off one of those just behind the gill plate in one bite.

(This post edited by wader on 02/28/2003)
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top