What about Atlantic Highlands?
If you are in North Jersey, you may find it easier and quicker to go to Atlantic Highlands. It is exit 117 of the GSP. Angler and Sea Tiger are both good daytime fluke boats. Captain Dan does the night bass fishing on the Angler and he is outstanding.
I have never been on the boat, but I have heard a lot of good things about the Seahorse. He runs a 3/4 day trip in the morning and a 3:30-8:30 fluke trip in the afternoon. Like I said, i have never been on the boat but I have had several guys who have fished out of Atl Hghlnds for years tell me good things about it.
There is a new boat in Perth Amboy,too, the Seahawk. Never been on it but i hear they catch fish.
Nothing against any of the boats that were mentioned, i am sure they are great boats. Atlantic Highlands is probably a lot closer then Sheepshead Bay for you, though.