Slimed...
It is hard to go by what brand of paint works for others. You can be in the same general area but get growth of one type or another that someone else may not get just by being farther up a creek or river in more stagnent water.
The most effective paint I have used and I have used them all over the years (not all brands of course but all types) is the VC Offshore with Teflon. It also has the lowest coefficient for drag with means more speed and less gas. At $200 per gallon but having to paint only every third year, anyone can do the math for themselves.
Back to you slime problem, 4 knots is a lot to lose, I don't even want to know how much fuel you were burning. I tried to do some reading on the cayenne pepper thing, have to weed through a lot of southerners trying to apply for a patent for the great idea everyone thinks they though of, so they can sue the company who winds up putting it in their paint at the factory and cash in......
Anyway, back to your situation again, it seems everyone who uses it says it works and it seems a best-guess estimate on the recipe is 4 ounces of cayenne pepper to a gallon of paint.
I think I would also just put some Biolux additive in with my paint if I was having a problem like yours. A 4 knot loss for marine growth is too much money for gas trying to push the boat. I use the VC Offshore for my hull but this paint is not compatible on aluminum and I use the Biolux for my aluminum outboard bracket. I can tell you it works.
As others have advised........it is best to use your boat regularly.