Hi Mike, thanks for the kind words.
I don't use any of the different baitrunner reels, so I have no real opinion worth sharing on the subject.
But I will say this, despite some on this site's contention that I overly shill for Shimano, I will ALWAYS give them first shot at any new reel I might be interested in.
Here's why:
1/ That company spends like heck in the product development part of tackle manufacturing - they don't always hit the target 100%, but they do try very hard. That research costs good money and they need to recoup it in the price of their products - thus they will almost never be the least expensive option. But usually will be the best engineered. Some of their stuff is a bit "out there" price-wise, but you really can't question the engineered-in quality of any of it.
2/ Many here know that I work on reels for members of this site gratis - for the cost of the parts only. Its not something I talk up, because God knows I've got a full plate doing my own thing. But if there's a problem with a reel and some reason not to ship it out, it frequently comes to me for last-chance service. Think of me as a resource of last resort. Now the "secret" is out, I suppose. Oh well.
I don't do all the many brands of reels out there. But one thing's for sure, if its a Shimano product, I stand a better than good chance of getting the parts and makeing that reel whole again.
If I need a part for a Shimano reel, all I need do is bring up the Shimano site, look up the reel and download the appropriate .pdf file. Then a quick call to Shimano directly, and the part is on its way. Try that with Daiwa, Okuma or any of the other players. Goos luck even finding the proper schematic.
Even Abu - as great as they are about parts - doesn't have a huge reserve of older reel schematics on their site - which forces me to look at third-party sources for parts schematics - with spotty results - at best. Or make a phone call to Abu in Spirit Lake, Iowa and wade thru a 30 minute conversation with CS searching for the appropriate part.
3/ If its a small part that's required to get a reel up and running then Shimano usually insists on sending it no charge, inclusive of the shipping. How the heck can you beat that?
So for me its a no brainer - Shimano comes first, then all the other brands line - regardless of reel type.
best, Lep