Saltwater Fishing Discussion Board Including Inshore Fishing, Offshore Fishing, Saltwater Fly Fishing and Kayak Fishing

Who has the best pizza in the Tri-State area, I would say the top three are:

1. King Umberto’s, corner Meecham Ave & Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont.
2. Carmelas, Merrick Rd., Massapequa
3. Umberto’s, Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park

MakoMatt

(This post edited by MakoMatt on 08/08/2003)

meterman305

Joined: 03/08/2003
Posts: 187
Location: Broad Channel, NY

posted 08/08/2003 08:16 PM

The best pizza was Pizza City in Howard Beach. Since they are gone these would be my top 3.

1. New Park Pizza in Howard Beach
2. Carlo's on Jamaica Ave. off Woodhaven Blvd.
3. Pizza Park on Ave. U in Brooklyn.

paulh

Joined: 11/29/2000
Posts: 1372

posted 08/08/2003 08:41 PM

Carlos Sicilian is good, but in general can't hold a candle to Joe's that occupied that location during my earlier chilhood.

The best sicilian was from Maria's Bakery, Jamiaca Ave and 87th street, probably long gone.

Howard Beach, the Old Lennies, New Park (oh yeah), good stuff.

Dani House of Pizza on Lefferts across from Regents Row may have been the best.

Been awhile since I lived in Queens, still searching for good LI pizza.

My job frequently takes me to the NJ from Boonton to Whippany, the pizza over there is actually better than LI, what's up with that ??

"It seems the harder I fish the luckier I get"

F/V Emily S

meterman305

Joined: 03/08/2003
Posts: 187
Location: Broad Channel, NY

posted 08/08/2003 09:12 PM

Yes, you are right I should have specified the Sicilain at Carlo's

LkyLindy

Joined: 11/12/2000
Posts: 3272
Location: StonyBrook

posted 08/08/2003 10:18 PM

Now Hold it Right there

Best Pizza in Suffolk-
Colloseos in Port Jeff Station
Best pizza in the tristate area-
Frank Pepes in New Haven Conn.

got health?
WANT HEALTH?
www.thenaturalonline.com

MagillaGorilla

Joined: 03/04/2002
Posts: 958
Location: STATEN ISLAND

posted 08/08/2003 10:57 PM

denino's, staten island. billy40 vouch for me here.

ps im fat so that makes me an expert

Mr. Chris "Magilla"
fishkillerchris@aol.com

sam843

Joined: 05/30/2002
Posts: 2945
Location: Sheepshead bay

posted 08/08/2003 11:04 PM

Zagat said only god can make better pizza

And they're right

Totonno's down in Coney Island

Damm why did you guys start this thread
Now I got a jones for Totonno's pie

MEMBER OF THE T.P.T. CLUB 2x

meterman305

Joined: 03/08/2003
Posts: 187
Location: Broad Channel, NY

posted 08/08/2003 11:42 PM

Yes how could I forget about Totonno's

Capthookem

Joined: 08/30/2002
Posts: 935
Location: Flemish Cap

posted 08/08/2003 11:53 PM

Pepes in New Haven

Capt. H

bobbo

Joined: 04/27/2002
Posts: 1298
Location: margaritaville

posted 08/09/2003 07:12 AM

paulh

Did you ever try the Resorviour tavern in Booton? It's on intervale road right behind the Jersey City resorvor on rt. 46. They make their own sausage and got great pie.

(This post edited by bobbo on 04/18/2004)

artie k

Joined: 04/16/2002
Posts: 145
Location: lindenhurst

posted 08/09/2003 07:44 AM

Mako...if your in the Elmont area and think umberto's is good try primivera their right down the street on meachem ave...Another place that makes really good pizza but has a lousey name is pizza express in copaigue..Inever bought a pie from there cause of the name til this year...I was missing out,Really good stuff...

slobs need love too

captaintrips

Joined: 10/19/2002
Posts: 31
Location: brooklyn

posted 08/09/2003 05:02 PM

Best pizza?

1. Totonos,Coney Island 2. Lombardi's, Little Italy 3. Grimaldi's,under Bklyn bridge honerable mention: spumoni garden,bensonhurst

mojoe

Joined: 10/01/2001
Posts: 4694
Location: ><)))):> ~~ THE JAMAICA BAY TRIANGLE ~~ <:))))><

posted 08/09/2003 05:37 PM

~~~.><)))):> <:((((>< ~~~

~~~ hey its BROTHERS PIZZA ON PORTRICHMONDAVE/FOREST AVE STATEN ISLAND "YOU TRYED THE REST NOW YOU GOT THE BEST" {LOL} SO YOU DONT THINK SO MAGILLAGORILLA! (-: ~~~ MOJOE~~~ >< Wink

))):>

(This post edited by mojoe on 08/09/2003)

EAT FISH AND LIVE LONGER!!!

BassinBilly

Joined: 05/04/2002
Posts: 157
Location: Mahopac NY

posted 08/09/2003 05:48 PM

Bensonhurst Brooklyn

1. D'VINCI'S PIZZA

2. J&V PIZZIA

anything out side of brooklyn isn't pizza.

(This post edited by BassinBilly on 08/09/2003)

Seacurity

Joined: 07/18/2003
Posts: 1161
Location: Brooklyn

posted 08/09/2003 06:10 PM

Best Pizza

Brooklyn has always and still has the best pizza around. CaptainTrip is on the money with his picks.

1. Tutonnos in Coney Island
2. Grimaldi under the Brooklyn Bridge
3. Spumoni Gardens 86th st.(Square)
4. DiVinchi 18th ave (Square)
5. Joe & Pats Victory Blvd in Staten Island makes a thin crust round that is delicious.

There is a pizzeria on avenue J in Brooklyn that makes a great pie as well but I forget the name.